Sample Scholarship Essays

O Pioneers

O Pioneers! O Pioneers! After reading the novel, O Pioneers!, it was hard to judge whether it was a tragedy or a triumph. I think the answer you are looking for would be a triumph. The only way I see it as a tragedy is that Emil and Maria died. I knew, since page six of the book, that they were destined to be together. It kind of broke my heart to see later on that she had married someone else. But when her and Emil got shot, I thought it may finish as a tragedy.

But overall, I would see it as a triumph in the way that the Bergson’s finally got what they wanted out of their land. It made them rich. Also, Alexandra and Carl finally married. And being that the whole novel was basically based on “the land”, they were triumphant in getting what they risked, what they longed for. In my opinion, I think the land broke the characters rather than the characters breaking the land.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

Of course the characters had to plant and sew the fields, but they did that every year. It took the forever, it seemed like, for the land to break them. That’s what the Bergson’s had worked for their whole life. The land pulls the family together and makes them work hard to get what they want,..money, happiness. It makes them happy. So yes, the land does break them more than they break the land.

In considering Cather’s characters, I don’t think they become fully Americanized within a generation. At the beginning of the novel, it seems like they are more in tuned with the rest of America. They are economically stable. But when Carl comes back on his first visit, Lou and Oscar scorn him about burning Wall Street. Obviously, America is building and becoming more advanced.

While still in Nebraska, people are relying on their crops to get them by. They are still dwelling on their traits, beliefs, and actions that past generations had. Romantic love in this particular novel is very hard to judge whether it is necessary for human happiness. I don’t think that it was meant to be the moral of the story, or that love was the basis of this particular novel, but I do think that after reading this that it was necessary in order to be happy. Of course, in one instance, love did end in heartbreak, desolation, and destruction with the scenario of Emil and Maria. But in every story, there has to be a sad moment or a fatality that occurs. But overall, it seemed like Alexandra wasn’t going to be happy unless Carl came back and she could be with him.

Also, she acted as if her money didn’t make her as happy as he did. Lou and Oscar also had love in their life. They moved away from the land in order to marry. Love took them over, not the land or the desire to be rich. So yes, I do think that love is necessary for human happiness.

Physically, I consider the men in the novel to be the strongest. But if you look at what the people in the novel had to overcome, emotionally, I think the women were stronger. Well into the novel, Lou and Oscar wanted to get rid of the land because they didn’t believe that it was worth anything. They kind of gave up. But Alexandra, being the strong one of the family, hung in there and convinced them that it would one day be worth a lot more than when they started out.

Alexandra, throughout the whole novel had to deal with some big tragedies. Her mother, father and brother dying. Her best friend dying, Carl walking in and out of her life, and having Lou and Oscar on her back all the time. She was made to be the strongest character of all. I found that the women of this novel to be stronger than the men.

I never really considered generational values all that important until I read this story. While trying to wear Alexandra’s shoes, it made me realize that the things we carry on generation after generation keep getting more and more valuable. For example, farming that land meant more to John Bergson than anything it seemed like. He wanted to keep that land for generations to come because he knew it would be worth a good amount. Alexandra wanted to keep the land in order to have a better lifestyle. It seems like today, no one is worried about farming the land in order to survive in the real world.

It seems that in reality, people have to go to college and get an education in order to make it in the world. The concerns, anxieties, and dreams of the characters do not seem relevant to the modern world today. English Essays.

‘O Pioneers’

Until the late eighteenth century, any land located beyond the Alleghany mountains
was believed to be savage, uninhabited land. Thus, it became known as the American
frontier. According to Turner, the definition of frontier means, “the meeting point
between savagery and civilization and a region of sparse settlement.” 1 With the
overwhelming number of frontiersmen invading this uninhabited land, many myths about
winning the West arose, some containing truth, while others neglecting to tell the truth
about treatment of Indians. Many of these myths referred to them as being the victims of
white man’s progress. In the short tale, O Pioneers, written by Willa Cather in 1913, tells
a tale of the oncoming future of the Great Plains. Although this tale tells about the great
fortune of the plains, it forgets to mention the heartaches of the Native Americans.


Willa Cather was born December 7 , 1873 in a town west of Winchester, Virginia.2
In 1884, the Cather’s moved their four children to a town called Red Cloud in Nebraska
where they arrived to a place uninhabited, but with much fortune and hard work ahead of
them. 3In 1890, Willa attended the University of Nebraska-Lincoln where she gained the
knowledge and creativity to write such beautiful work. In her first works, Willa’s
animosity towards Nebraska was relevant in her work. 4After she went east in 1896 and
became editor of McClure’s Magazine and gained success, her feeling toward Nebraska
changed, which was evident in “The Bohemian Girl,” in 1912. 5
When she published O Pioneers in 1913, many of her memories of childhood and
life on the prairie were depicted in the tale. For example, a phrase in the tale O Pioneers is
a memoir of the Divide when she was a child:
“The variegated field, are all one colour now; the pastures, the stubble, the roads,
the sky the same keaden gray. The frozen ground is so hard it bruises the foot to walk in
the roads or in the ploughed fields.” 6
After the quick rise of her successful career, Cather wrote many more wonderful
works that revolved around her home . . . the Divide. Willa Cather died on April 24, 1947
in New York City as a celebrated person and a talented author.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now


The Great Plains, America’s largest openland frontier, may be defined as the region
between the 98th meridian on the east and the Rocky Mountains on the west and
extending from southern Texas up to the forested area in northeastern Canada. 7 The
climate of the Great Plains is distinguished by its unpredictable weather, low rainfall, high
winds and immoderate temperatures throughout the seasons.
When the settlers from most European countries came to inhabit the new,
unsettled land, they had no idea what was in store for them concerning weather and the
Indian tribes of the land. The plains Indians created the worst threat to the white man that
began to advance into the frontier. These tribesmen were difficult to control since they
were nomadic and took their homes with them and lived off the land. 8The Indians
followed the buffalo, as it was their main source of food and clothing. When the white
man drove the buffalo off the land, the Indians were forced to stay on reservations created
by the white man. Reservations were made because the frontiersman couldn’t obey their
property regulations.


In the book, O Pioneers, it does not reflect upon the Indians right for the land, in
fact, it disregards them from the life of the Divide.In 1854, treaties with the tribal
Indians began, which paved the way for white settlers to open up the plains territory. 9
These treaties initiated settlement of Nebraska, where the tale O Pioneers takes place.
The aborigines occupied the land as tribal land, but as Klose states, it was not privately
owned. Therefore, the government made the treaties so the territorial ownership by the
tribes would not be recognized, keeping the whites out. However, intrusions could not be
stopped. The white man did not want free, fertile land to go to waste on the Indians
when, Christian men lived in want.” 10 The federal government found it impossible to
enforce the obedience to its own laws much less agreements with Indians. An example of
this land intrusion in the book O Pioneers is stated on page 3811, when Alexandra
Bergson, the main character in the book, wants to buy 1,400 more acres of land, the only
concern is where she will get the money to buy it.
“The thing to do is sell our cattle and what little corn we buy at the Linstrum
place. Then take out two loans on our half-sections.”
In this conversation she is having with her two brothers, there is no concern for the
Indian Tribes. Alexandra, like many other frontier men and women, ignore the fact that
the Indians have rights to the land. Instead, many Native American tribes were forced off
their land or their “mother” as many Indians refer to it as. Many settlers think the land is
only good enough for white Christian men and the land is of no worth to the Native tribes
of the plains.
The only mention of any type of Indian on the Divide is the character Ivar.
Although, there is no formal introduction that he is an Indian, the characters of the book
refer to him as “Crazy Ivar” because he is said to be able to talk to animals. I believe that
Ivar is an Indians because many Native Americans believe they are one with the earth and
nature.An example in the book which leads the reader to believe he is an Indian is, “he
disliked the litter of human dwellings: he preferred the cleanness and tidiness of the wild
sod.” In my opinion, this refers him as being one with the land. An example of the
pioneers forcing Ivar off his land is stated on page 52, “when Ivar lost his land through
mismanagement over a dozen years ago.” Indians usually lost their land if they had any in
the times of the “winning of the west.”This example again states that the Native tribes
were eventually forced off their home land and as a result went to live on the white man’s
reservations.


In the short tale, O Pioneers, by Willa Cather, 1913 tells a tale about the oncoming
future of the Great Plains. Although this tale is told about the great fortune of the
pioneers, the book and the myths that were created during this time about the Winning of
the West, forget to mention the heartaches and loss of land among the Native tribes.


Category: English

x

Hi!
I'm Abigail

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out